Your browser does not support JavaScript!

Navigating the Shift: Why Employers Are Cutting Entry-Level Roles in Favor of Experienced Hires

General Report July 28, 2025
goover

  • As of July 28, 2025, the global employment landscape has witnessed a dramatic pivot, characterized by a considerable reduction in entry-level positions in favor of seasoned professionals. This shift is largely driven by the proliferation of AI-powered recruitment tools, economic uncertainties, and a growing demand for immediate productivity from hires. In recent analyses, job postings for entry-level roles have decreased by approximately 33% year-over-year, catalyzing a competitive environment that severely impacts new graduates and internship seekers. The current employment rate for recent college graduates has hit concerning levels, with an unemployment rate of 5.8%—the highest since the commencement of the post-pandemic recovery. This precarious scenario underscores the intensified struggle for entry-level opportunities, as new graduates now find themselves vying against mid-career professionals for entry-level positions. Regional disparities further compound these challenges, showcasing nuanced responses to market pressures. For instance, India's workforce is evolving towards a more skills-based hiring approach, driven by automation and the need for specialized talent. Similarly, the U.S. faces a cross-generational crisis as both young and older workers grapple with the effects of AI-driven hiring systems. This report analyzes the implications of these trends, offering insights into potential strategies that can be employed by new talent to navigate an increasingly complex recruitment landscape. Overall, the future of employment hinges on aligning workforce capabilities with technological advancements and business imperatives.

Shifting Hiring Trends and Preference for Experience

  • Decline in entry-level positions

  • The landscape of entry-level positions has seen a significant decline as companies recalibrate their hiring strategies amid evolving market dynamics. Reports indicate that job postings for entry-level roles have plummeted by as much as 33% compared to the previous year, reflecting a broader trend towards cost-cutting and efficiency that has been exacerbated by the introduction of artificial intelligence (AI) in recruitment processes. According to a June 2025 report by Business Insider, the use of automated résumé filtering systems has made the job market even more stringent, filtering out a large number of applicants before any human evaluation can occur. This has disproportionately affected new graduates, who traditionally rely on entry-level roles as a means of launching their careers. With a reported unemployment rate of 5.8% among recent college graduates, the worst since the post-pandemic recovery began, it is clear that young talent is facing intensified competition for events that have historically provided a pathway into the workforce. Many candidates now find themselves competing with mid-career professionals who are applying for the same entry-level jobs, further diminishing the job prospects for newly minted graduates.

  • Increase in mid-career hiring

  • In stark contrast to the decline of entry-level positions, there has been a marked increase in the hiring of mid-career professionals, a phenomenon driven by both the disappearing middle management roles—a trend referred to as 'the Great Flattening'—and the heightened demand for experienced talent among employers. The World Economic Forum's Future of Jobs Report 2025 indicates that many organizations are restructuring to favor a flatter management style, leading to a rise in competition for roles that require seasoned professionals. As firms increasingly prioritize hiring experienced individuals capable of contributing immediately with proven skill sets, the market for mid-career talent has evolved dramatically. The challenge for mid-career professionals, however, lies in navigating this new employment landscape, where the competition not only includes their peers but also younger candidates equipped with advanced digital skills and AI literacy. Moreover, many seasoned professionals are being forced to downsize their expectations, seeking lower-paying or lower-ranking jobs as they adapt to the changing environment.

  • Employer risk mitigation through experience

  • Employers are increasingly recognizing the worth of hiring experienced candidates as a strategy to mitigate risks associated with productivity and adaptability in the evolving workforce landscape. The pressures of economic uncertainty, along with the ongoing integration of AI technologies into business processes, have prompted employers to seek candidates who can hit the ground running—with minimal need for training. This trend is becoming particularly pronounced, as companies anticipate that automation will displace a significant proportion of tasks traditionally assigned to entry-level workers. Reports show that by 2025, organizations plan to reduce roles susceptible to automation, with many pivoting toward hiring individuals with extensive industry knowledge and specialized skill sets. This drive for experience is reflected through the findings of the Goldman Sachs AI Adoption Tracker, which indicated that while AI adoption is growing, it has yet to have a noticeable adverse impact on overall employment rates; rather, it appears to be reshaping the types of skills employers prioritize. As companies firmly establish their positions in this increasingly complex landscape, the preference for experience serves as a buffer against the risks associated with rapid technological change and economic unpredictability.

Role of AI and Automation in Screening

  • AI résumé filtering and bias

  • Artificial intelligence (AI) has fundamentally transformed hiring processes through automated résumé filtering, which offers significant efficiency advantages. AI systems can analyze large volumes of applications much faster than human recruiters, quickly identifying candidates who meet essential job criteria. However, this advantage comes with substantial risks, particularly concerning bias. AI tools reliant on historical data often reflect the biases inherent in that data, leading to systematic discrimination against particular demographic groups. Reports of AI tools, such as Amazon's now-scrapped hiring algorithm that discriminated against women, underscore the importance of addressing these biases. To mitigate these issues, organizations are urged to adopt diverse training datasets, implement regular audits, and maintain human oversight to ensure fair hiring practices.

  • Efficiency gains favoring seasoned candidates

  • The integration of AI in recruitment has led to marked efficiency gains that appear to favor candidates with established experience. As companies increasingly adopt AI for tasks ranging from resume parsing to predictive hiring, the speed and accuracy of candidate assessment have improved significantly. For instance, AI systems can quickly match candidates to job descriptions, expediting the screening process and enabling recruiters to focus on high-potential candidates. This trend is reflected in data indicating that up to 40% of HR departments expect to utilize AI tools by the end of 2025. However, this efficiency gain often benefits mid-career professionals over entry-level candidates, as seasoned individuals fit more closely with the established data patterns on which these AI systems are trained.

  • Limitations of mass layoffs predictions

  • Despite the fervor surrounding AI's potential to transform labor markets, predictions of massive layoffs attributed to AI implementation have not materialized as anticipated. Recent analyses, including findings from Goldman Sachs and Brookings, illustrate that while AI is becoming increasingly integrated into corporate operations, it has not generally led to significant workforce reductions. Instead, findings indicate that AI adoption is often correlated with firm growth and increased employment, particularly in technology sectors. While entry-level roles face the greatest exposure to automation, the broader impact of AI remains nuanced as most job functions still require human input. Hence, firms are currently adopting AI as a complement to human roles rather than as a wholesale replacement.

Impact on New Graduates and Entry-Level Workers

  • Internship scarcity

  • The landscape of internships has become increasingly challenging for new graduates due to the rising prevalence of artificial intelligence (AI) in the workforce. Traditionally viewed as a vital stepping stone for early-career professionals, internships are now threatened by automation. According to a recent study, entry-level roles that typically required minimal experience are being replaced or supplemented by AI technologies, diminishing the pool of available internships. With generative AI capable of performing tasks such as data entry and drafting reports more efficiently and at a lower cost, companies are reallocating resources, leading to a notable decrease in internship opportunities. Reports indicate that applications for internships have spiked by 14% per available position, intensifying competition among candidates. This trend indicates a worrying trajectory for those transitioning from academia to the workforce.

  • Graduate job crunch

  • New graduates are facing unprecedented hurdles in securing employment as the entry-level job market contracts significantly. Data released recently shows that the number of advertised positions for new graduates has plummeted by 33% compared to the previous year. Much of this decline is attributed to cautious hiring practices spurred by economic uncertainty and the integration of AI for various routine tasks that graduates would typically perform. For instance, companies like IBM have automated a staggering 94% of their routine HR functions, reshaping the entry-level landscape. The rapid growth of AI capabilities in summarizing, collating, and performing research tasks thus threatens to eliminate many traditional entry-level roles in sectors such as finance, consulting, and digital services. Consequently, graduates now find themselves searching for fewer opportunities amid a competitive and evolving job market.

  • Adapting to AI-driven competition

  • To navigate the challenges of an AI-dominated job market, new graduates must cultivate skills that align with the expectations of modern employers. AI literacy has emerged as a crucial competency, with two-thirds of employers expressing a preference for candidates equipped with AI capabilities over those with mere experience. This shift necessitates that graduates become adept in using AI tools like ChatGPT and others to enhance their productivity and effectiveness. Furthermore, the job application process now increasingly relies on AI-driven screening technologies, meaning that candidates need to demonstrate not only their technical skills but also their adaptability to innovative tools. In response to the evolving workforce demands, there has been a marked increase in the availability of online courses focusing on AI skills and other critical areas. Graduates are advised to actively engage in upskilling through these courses while building an AI-compatible portfolio that showcases their ability to thrive in a technologically advanced environment.

Regional and Sectoral Variations

  • India’s shift to value-driven hiring

  • India's hiring landscape is undergoing significant changes as businesses pivot from high-volume recruitment towards a value-driven approach. This transformation is primarily influenced by automation, artificial intelligence (AI), and broader economic pressures that necessitate a focus on quality over quantity. According to the NASSCOM Talent Pulse 2024 report, an overwhelming 65% of IT companies are now targeting specialized roles such as AI/ML engineers and data scientists instead of traditional coding positions. This strategic shift underscores an increasing demand for candidates with specific skills, as opposed to a general set of capabilities common in entry-level roles.

  • The impact of this shift is multifaceted; skill-based hiring has gained momentum, reflecting a growing preference for certifications and project portfolios over traditional educational credentials. In its 2025 hiring charter, a prominent Indian conglomerate expressed the need for adaptive capacity and digital problem-solving abilities as critical traits sought in new hires. This is a marked departure from previous metrics that emphasized academic pedigree or tenure, indicating a strategic alignment with the demands of the modern workforce.

  • Moreover, technology plays a crucial role in this evolving landscape. AI-driven tools for resume parsing and assessments have gained traction, with 48% of organizations implementing such technologies by 2025, up from 19% in 2021. These technologies not only streamline recruitment processes but also enhance the alignment between candidate qualifications and job requirements, thereby mitigating hiring biases that may exclude potential talent.

  • U.S. cross-generational labor crisis

  • The U.S. job market in 2025 reflects a complex crisis affecting all generations, particularly as the influence of AI-driven hiring systems intensifies. In a labor environment characterized by automation and corporate restructuring, job seekers from Gen Z to older generations are facing unprecedented challenges in securing employment. The unemployment rate among recent graduates has risen to 5.8%, with many losing out on entry-level opportunities due to increasingly competitive applicant pools that include seasoned professionals.

  • This situation is exacerbated by a phenomenon dubbed 'the Great Flattening', which describes the widespread elimination of middle management roles as organizations streamline operations for efficiency. As detailed in reports from Business Insider, experienced workers are being forced to apply for lower-paying positions or pivot their careers entirely, leading to a workforce that is not only more seasoned but also more diverse in age and experience levels.

  • Age discrimination remains a critical concern, particularly for older applicants who often face significant barriers when trying to re-enter the job market. Studies indicate that older job seekers are disproportionately affected by algorithmic hiring practices that may disregard nontraditional career paths, gaps in employment, or unique experiences. This situation underscores the urgent need for strategies that enable all job seekers, regardless of age, to navigate the modern job landscape effectively.

  • Sectoral reliance on experienced talent

  • Various sectors are demonstrating an increased reliance on experienced talent, reflective of the broader trend toward valuing expertise and advanced skills. The World Economic Forum's Future of Jobs Report 2025 identifies specific industries such as healthcare, cybersecurity, and green energy as particularly active in their pursuit of seasoned professionals. In California, for instance, projections indicate that registered nursing and information security roles will see substantial job growth through 2028, emphasizing the necessity for skills that align with contemporary industry demands.

  • This reliance on experienced hires correlates with an overall decrease in entry-level roles as automation and AI reshape operational models. Notably, data indicates that competitive applications for junior positions are flooding in not just from fresh graduates but also from mid-career professionals adjusting to the changing job market. Consequently, industries are redefining entry-level definitions, often seeking candidates who possess certifications or vocational training rather than solely relying on educational attainment.

  • Overall, industry professionals are well aware that remaining adaptable and continuously enhancing skill sets through reskilling initiatives is essential. Companies are gradually shifting focus towards hiring individuals with proven capabilities and adaptability to advance their business outcomes effectively in this dynamic landscape.

Strategies for New Talent to Navigate the Landscape

  • Embracing skills-based hiring

  • The shift toward skills-based hiring represents a significant change in recruitment practices, whereby employers are increasingly prioritizing actionable skills over formal education credentials. This approach allows companies to tap into a broader talent pool and incorporates candidates from diverse backgrounds, including boot camp graduates and self-taught professionals. Research indicates a notable decline in job postings that require university degrees, especially for roles in tech, suggesting that organizations are realizing the value of practical qualifications.

  • Organizations embracing skills-based hiring find that it not only helps fill critical talent gaps but also fosters a culture of innovation and adaptability. This shift is especially crucial in today’s labor market, which favors candidates with hands-on abilities that align with job requirements. By focusing on demonstrable skills, companies can build teams that are more diverse and capable of responding dynamically to changing market demands.

  • Building AI-compatible portfolios

  • In an era where AI is deeply intertwined with recruitment practices, new talent is encouraged to develop AI-compatible portfolios. Such portfolios not only showcase traditional achievements but also highlight abilities related to technology, data literacy, and problem-solving, aligning with the demands of modern employers. Candidates should leverage platforms like GitHub for tech skills, create blogs detailing their learning journeys, and utilize social media to share insights relevant to their fields. This proactive approach allows candidates to demonstrate their capabilities in a way that speaks to the criteria used by AI-driven recruitment tools.

  • Additionally, as AI technologies continue to revolutionize job functions through automation and augmentation, individuals should focus on developing skills that complement AI rather than compete against it. Graduates might consider courses in AI ethics, machine learning basics, or project management to enhance their portfolios, preparing them for roles where collaboration between humans and machines will be essential.

  • Continuous upskilling and networking

  • The necessity for continuous upskilling cannot be overstated in the current professional landscape. As industries evolve and technology accelerates, new graduates and entry-level workers are urged to engage in lifelong learning through various means, such as online courses, industry certifications, and attending professional workshops. By continually updating their skills, individuals can better position themselves against the competition posed by more experienced candidates, enhancing their employability.

  • Networking remains another crucial strategy for navigating today’s job market. Building relationships within the industry can provide insights into unseen job opportunities and trends that may not be immediately apparent through conventional job searches. Joining professional organizations, attending conferences, and leveraging platforms like LinkedIn can help new talent not only connect with industry leaders but also gain mentorship and guidance—resources that can prove invaluable when starting a career or pivoting roles.

Future Outlook: Balancing Innovation and Talent Development

  • Forecast for entry-level roles

  • The future of entry-level roles appears precarious as employers increasingly prioritize experienced hires and advanced skills. According to recent studies, particularly the World Economic Forum's Future of Jobs Report 2025, 40% of employers are expected to reduce entry-level positions due to the automation of tasks traditionally assigned to these roles. This trend suggests a shrinking market for first-time job seekers, who are likely to face intensified competition from more experienced candidates. As a result, universities and vocational institutions must adapt their curricula to better prepare graduates, emphasizing practical skills, internships, and co-curricular experiences that align with market needs.

  • Policy and corporate training initiatives

  • To counter the decline in entry-level opportunities, there is a compelling need for both policy and corporate-driven training initiatives. Organizations are increasingly recognizing that they cannot simply rely on experience; investing in talent development through comprehensive training programs will be essential. Policies encouraging companies to engage in upskilling and reskilling their workforce can help foster a more adaptable labor market. Collaborative efforts between businesses and educational institutions are also crucial. These partnerships can create tailored training programs that align with future job requirements, promoting a fluid transition between academia and the workforce.

  • Co-evolution of AI and human skills

  • The co-evolution of AI technologies and human skills presents both challenges and opportunities. As noted in the analysis by Brookings, while AI integration tends to favor highly skilled workers, it also leads to a significant reshaping of job roles. This dynamic illustrates the need for workers, particularly those entering the job market, to cultivate a set of skills that complement AI capabilities—such as creativity, strategic oversight, and emotional intelligence. Employers will begin to seek candidates who can thrive alongside AI systems rather than compete against them, placing new emphasis on interdisciplinary capabilities. Consequently, future professionals will need to embrace continuous learning and adaptability as core competencies.

Wrap Up

  • The inclination of employers towards hiring experienced candidates emphasizes a strategic focus on productivity and adaptability in a rapidly evolving market. This shift undeniably raises significant barriers for new graduates, who must now grapple with a landscape that is not only more competitive but also increasingly reliant on advanced skills and AI literacy. To remain viable, early-career professionals must adopt targeted strategies, including acquiring skills-based credentials, enhancing their understanding of AI applications, and engaging in proactive networking to broaden their opportunities. As we look forward, a collaborative effort between organizations and policymakers is imperative to foster a supportive ecosystem. This would involve initiatives aimed at bolstering internship programs, implementing robust upskilling measures, and ensuring equitable AI practices to maintain a healthy pipeline of emerging talent. Moreover, the necessity for a balanced approach that harmonizes technology with the nurturing of human potential remains critical for sustainable workforce development. In this landscape, the coexistence of AI and human capabilities will not only redefine job functions but also create new professional avenues that emphasize continual learning and adaptability, ensuring that the workforce evolves in tandem with technological advancements.

Glossary

  • AI Hiring: The integration of artificial intelligence technologies into recruitment processes, notably for screening candidates through automated résumé filtering. While AI enhances efficiency by quickly matching candidates to job descriptions, it can also introduce biases based on historical data, raising concerns about equitable hiring practices.
  • Entry-Level: Positions typically designated for individuals at the beginning of their careers, often requiring minimal work experience. Recent trends show a significant reduction in these roles as employers increasingly favor experienced candidates, leading to heightened competition for recent graduates and internship seekers.
  • Mid-Career: Professionals who have several years of work experience, usually seeking advancement in their careers. The demand for mid-career professionals has increased amid shifts in hiring trends, with many companies prioritizing this group over entry-level candidates to meet immediate productivity needs.
  • Skills-Based Hiring: A recruitment approach that prioritizes demonstrated skills and competencies over formal education credentials. This trend enables organizations to access a broader talent pool by valuing practical qualifications and experience, making it especially relevant in today's evolving job market.
  • Automation: The use of technology, such as AI and machine learning, to perform tasks traditionally assigned to humans. In the context of recruitment, automation affects the availability of entry-level roles, as many tasks previously done by new hires are increasingly being handled by AI systems.
  • Talent Alignment: The strategic process of ensuring that the skills and competencies of a workforce meet the specific needs of an organization. This alignment has become crucial as companies strive to integrate both technological advancements and human potential in their operations.
  • Upskilling: The process of teaching current employees new skills or enhancing existing competencies to adapt to changing job demands. For new graduates, upskilling is increasingly important as they compete with experienced professionals and navigate a job market heavily influenced by technology.
  • Regional Variation: Differences in hiring practices and job market conditions that occur across different geographic locations. For example, India's shift towards value-driven hiring reflects a growing need for specialized skills, while the U.S. faces challenges related to an aging workforce and cross-generational competition for jobs.
  • Generative AI: A form of artificial intelligence capable of producing text, audio, and other content based on prompts it receives. In the workforce, generative AI is impacting tasks such as data entry and report generation, further eroding traditional entry-level job opportunities.
  • The Great Flattening: A labor market phenomenon characterized by the reduction of middle management roles within organizations, leading to a more streamlined hierarchy. This trend has resulted in increased competition for available job positions, particularly affecting mid-career professionals.
  • Cross-Generational Labor Crisis: A situation where job seekers of all generations, from Gen Z to older workers, experience challenges in securing employment due to heightened competition and the impact of AI-driven hiring systems. This crisis highlights the need for organizations to address age discrimination in recruitment practices.

Source Documents