Your browser does not support JavaScript!

Navigating the Shrinking Entry-Level Job Market: The Rise of Experienced Hiring in the AI Era

General Report July 12, 2025
goover

  • As of July 12, 2025, the landscape of entry-level job opportunities is undergoing a significant transformation across global economies, driving a reduction in available positions for recent graduates. This contraction, a direct result of economic hesitance and the pervasive influence of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in the workforce, is characterized by a substantial 33% decline in job postings for entry-level roles compared to last year. Fields such as accounting and human resources are particularly affected, experiencing a fundamental shift in job requirements that often eliminates the need for fresh graduates. Employers are now favoring experienced professionals who can hit the ground running amid escalating uncertainties in the global job market and heightened competition for jobs.

  • Ongoing studies reveal a concerning drop in hiring plans, especially among small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) within the United States, where only 42% of CEOs foresee workforce increases in the upcoming year—the lowest number recorded since the survey's inception in 2003. Concurrently, economic pressures are driving graduates to settle for employment in roles that deviate from their education and career aspirations. An uptick in the unemployment rate among recent graduates reflects these challenges, with a detected 30% rise since late 2022, underscoring the severity of the current job market crunch. First-time job seekers are thus advised to employ strategies focused on upskilling, adaptability, and leveraging new technologies, including AI tools, to enhance their employment prospects.

  • In response to these challenges, regional policymakers are enacting initiatives designed to bolster youth employment. Governments in Singapore, China, and the United States have recognized the urgency of bridging the growing skills gap. For instance, Singapore's Economic Resilience Taskforce has reported a recovery in graduate employment rates, while China is implementing targeted programs aimed at the anticipated influx of graduates this year. Notably, the ASEAN region is also fostering collaboration in AI capabilities to enhance skill development across industries within member states. Amidst this turbulent landscape, first-time job seekers must embrace lifelong learning and cultivate human-centric competencies, ensuring their profiles remain competitive and relevant.

  • Overall, the interplay between technological advancements and evolving job market dynamics is reshaping employment strategies and career pathways for new graduates. This report offers critical insights into current trends, regional responses, and actionable recommendations to navigate a job market increasingly defined by demand for experienced talent over entry-level positions.

Current Landscape of Entry-Level Job Reduction

  • Declining entry-level hiring rates in key sectors

  • The landscape for entry-level positions has contracted significantly across multiple sectors, particularly influenced by economic hesitance and the rising prevalence of AI technologies. Recent reports note that employers are scaling back recruitment efforts, with a notable 33% drop in job postings for recent graduates compared to the previous year. This reduction is especially pronounced in professional sectors such as accounting and human resources, where reliance on AI has led to a transformation of entry-level job requirements, often eliminating the need for such positions altogether.

  • Data on record-low hiring plans

  • Current data reflects a concerning trend in the hiring practices of small and midsize businesses in the United States. According to a recent survey by Vistage, only 42% of CEOs anticipate increasing their workforce in the upcoming year, marking it as the lowest level since the survey began in 2003. This conservative outlook is compounded by further reports indicating that 13% of businesses are planning to reduce their workforce, an alarming sign reminiscent of hiring patterns experienced during the COVID-19 pandemic.

  • Graduate job-market crunch

  • As graduates from the Class of 2025 enter the workforce, they face unprecedented challenges in securing employment. The unemployment rate among recent college graduates has surged, with data indicating a 30% increase in unemployment since late 2022. A significant factor contributing to this crisis is the dual pressure of increased competition from a growing number of highly qualified graduates and the disruption caused by AI transforming traditional entry-point roles into automated functions.

  • Impact on first-time graduates

  • The implications of the shrinking job market extend deeply into the lives of first-time graduates. Many are compelled to seek employment in roles that do not align with their education or career aspirations. Reports show that graduates are increasingly taking up blue-collar jobs or positions traditionally not requiring a college degree, driven by the realization that the ROI of obtaining a degree is diminishing. With the number of job seekers outpacing available positions, many graduates face an arduous job search process, often resulting in prolonged periods of unemployment or underemployment.

Drivers Behind Preference for Experienced Workers

  • AI-driven automation in customer service and finance

  • The influence of Artificial Intelligence (AI) on the job market has been notably pronounced, especially within sectors such as customer service and finance. As highlighted in recent analyses, automation tools are transforming customer interactions by efficiently managing routine queries, thereby reducing the necessity for entry-level roles traditionally filled by recent graduates. In the finance sector, tasks like accounts payable and payroll management have increasingly been automated, necessitating a workforce that is not just adaptable but also skilled in higher-order analytical tasks. This shift significantly limits opportunities for those entering the job market without proven experience. Organizations are therefore prioritizing experienced professionals who can seamlessly integrate into these automated systems.

  • Role of digital transformation and productivity tools

  • The broader digital transformation across industries has further entrenched the preference for experienced workers. This transformation, driven by the constant enhancement of productivity tools, calls for a workforce proficient in navigating complex software and adapting to new technologies. Studies indicate that sectors embracing advanced digital tools are witnessing a preferment for candidates who not only possess technical skills but also have a proven track record in similar environments. As a result, organizations are looking for individuals who can demonstrate immediate value and minimize training time, further disadvantaging entry-level candidates.

  • Economic headwinds and talent risk aversion

  • Global economic uncertainties, including fluctuating market conditions and inflationary pressures, are compelling employers to adopt a risk-averse stance regarding hiring. According to findings from the International Labour Organization (ILO), companies facing economic headwinds prefer experienced talent who can operate effectively from day one, without the learning curve associated with newer entrants. This approach reduces perceived hiring risks and ensures stability during tumultuous economic periods. The preference for experienced workers reflects a desire to mitigate operational risks that startups or untested hires may pose to organizations navigating these challenges.

  • Skills gap fueling demand for proven expertise

  • The existing skills gap in the workforce is increasingly driving employers to seek out candidates with demonstrated expertise. Reports indicate that as industries evolve, the gap between required skills and those possessed by the available labor pool is widening. This situation is particularly evident in sectors heavily impacted by AI, where automation necessitates not only technical know-how but also strategic thinking and problem-solving abilities. Hiring experienced individuals mitigates the costs associated with extensive training programs and hastens the process of integrating new hires into teams, thereby accelerating project timelines and enhancing productivity.

Regional Responses and Initiatives

  • Singapore Economic Resilience Taskforce guidance

  • In recent developments, the Singapore Economic Resilience Taskforce (SERT) has emphasized the importance of support systems for fresh graduates entering the challenging job market. Established in April 2025, SERT aims to mitigate job uncertainties influenced by factors such as economic fluctuations and global tensions. As of July 2025, Manpower Minister Tan See Leng announced that the employment rate for graduates in June hit 51.9%, a notable increase compared to 47.9% in June 2024. This statistic reflects a robust labor market, particularly with 2, 400 available public sector positions suitable for fresh graduates, including engineering and software development roles. SERT's initiatives extend to expanding career guidance services to connect young job seekers with industry professionals. The government highlights the importance of nurturing young talent, urging businesses to invest in potential future leaders amidst a landscape marked by significant job market anxiety.

  • China’s tiered employment push for 2025 graduates

  • China's government is actively attempting to bolster employment prospects for the anticipated record 12.22 million graduates entering the workforce in 2025. The country has implemented a tiered strategy focusing on job creation, skills enhancement, and targeted support for disadvantaged students. Initiatives include recruitment fairs that directly connect students with provincial and national employers across various sectors like healthcare, AI, and education. Furthermore, new policies have been established to extend job expansion subsidies to social organizations, fostering an inclusive job market. Alongside these efforts, the Ministry of Education has launched over 2, 600 'micro-major' programs tailored to high-demand skills, reinforcing students' readiness for the job market. With continuous support from government platforms, the upcoming months will see extensive job fairs and initiatives designed to assist students in finding suitable employment.

  • ASEAN AI capability collaboration

  • The ASEAN region is increasingly focusing on collaboration in AI capabilities to address the evolving demands of the job market. As part of this initiative, member countries are pooling resources to strengthen talent development in AI and related fields, promoting skill enhancement across various sectors. Collaborative projects include joint workshops, training programs, and shared research initiatives aimed at increasing workforce competency in artificial intelligence. As of July 2025, this partnership underscores a collective commitment to bridging the skills gap and fostering innovation-driven employment opportunities within ASEAN nations, responding proactively to the rising significance of technology in the job market.

  • U.S. Skilled Technical Workforce policies

  • In the United States, there is a growing recognition of the need for a well-trained Skilled Technical Workforce (STW) to support the nation’s economic and security interests. Recent federal policies aim to revitalize the manufacturing sector by focusing on enhancing workforce training and addressing the shortage of skilled technical workers. Reports indicate that between 11.9% and 23.1% of the U.S. workforce fits into the STW category, which encompasses individuals who possess specialized skills but may not hold a four-year degree. Policymakers are urged to align educational initiatives with industry needs, emphasizing the importance of vocational training and apprenticeships to prepare workers for high-demand roles. Given the projected shortages in critical sectors such as semiconductor manufacturing, the implementation of support measures is crucial. The U.S. strategy advocates for targeted funding and comprehensive training programs, critical for maintaining competitive advantages in increasingly technological industries.

Strategies for First-Time Job Seekers

  • Cultivating human-centric soft skills

  • In a job market increasingly influenced by AI and automation, the emphasis on human-centric soft skills has never been more critical for first-time job seekers. As per recent analyses, while AI can perform many tasks traditionally assigned to entry-level positions, it still falls short in areas requiring empathy, creativity, and emotional intelligence. Candidates who can articulate their abilities in collaboration, storytelling, and ethical decision-making are poised to stand out. These skills enable graduates to interact effectively in diverse workplaces, foster teamwork, and navigate complex interpersonal dynamics, enhancing their attractiveness to potential employers.

  • Embracing lifelong learning and micro-credentials

  • The shelf life of knowledge is rapidly diminishing, underscoring the necessity for lifelong learning among job seekers. The ongoing evolution in technology demands that graduates adopt a mindset of continuous education rather than viewing their degrees as terminal qualifications. Online courses, boot camps, and initiatives offering micro-credentials in emerging fields can significantly enhance a first-time job seeker's profile. Platforms providing these learning opportunities, such as Coursera and Udemy, have seen astronomical growth in enrollments, reflecting the high demand for new skills correlating with industry needs. Therefore, actively pursuing such educational resources is essential to remain relevant and competitive.

  • Leveraging AI tools to augment applications

  • As AI permeates various industries, first-time job seekers are encouraged to utilize AI tools to enhance their job application processes. Harnessing AI-driven platforms for resume building, cover letter writing, and interview preparation can offer candidates a significant edge. The ability to demonstrate familiarity with AI technologies and tools not only showcases adaptability but also aligns with employer expectations for candidates. Experiments with AI functionalities, such as drafting or refining application materials through various digital platforms, can save time and refine submissions, increasing the likelihood of capturing employer interest.

  • Building portable experience through projects

  • In facing the challenges of a contracting entry-level job market, first-time job seekers should focus on building portable experience through diverse projects. Engaging in internships, volunteer work, or freelance projects allows graduates to amass tangible evidence of their skills and competencies while creating a portfolio that is easily transferable across roles and industries. This practical experience not only validates a candidate's capabilities but also illustrates proactivity and a readiness to learn—qualities highly regarded by employers today. By showcasing project outcomes and learned skills on platforms such as LinkedIn, candidates can enhance their visibility to recruiters and potential employers.

Outlook and Future Implications

  • Projected evolution of entry-level roles

  • As the job market continues to adapt to changing demands, the evolution of entry-level roles is projected to hinge significantly on technological advancements, particularly in artificial intelligence (AI). While automation may reduce traditional entry-level opportunities, new roles that require integration of both technical skills and human-centric capabilities are expected to emerge. These hybrid positions may combine tasks that require emotional intelligence, creativity, and complex problem-solving, suggesting that tomorrow's entry-level workers will need to be versatile and adaptable. The change is already observable, with discussions among industry leaders calling for a reevaluation of what qualifies as entry-level work in the AI era.

  • Long-term impact of AI on workforce structure

  • The long-term impact of AI on the workforce structure is still unfolding and presents both challenges and opportunities. As AI systems become increasingly integrated into various sectors, they are likely to shift not only the types of jobs available but also the skills required for those positions. Research indicates that while AI may lead to the displacement of some jobs, particularly in routine or manual tasks, it simultaneously drives the creation of new roles that demand higher-level cognitive skills. For instance, recent studies reveal that exposure to AI has not resulted in widespread job dissatisfaction or mental health decline among workers; instead, it may contribute positively to physical well-being by minimizing physically taxing work. This highlights the necessity for ongoing upskilling programs to equip workers with the competencies needed to thrive in an AI-driven economy.

  • Emerging hybrid roles blending technical and human skills

  • The rise of hybrid roles that blend technical and human skills is becoming increasingly evident in the current job market. As observed across various industries, positions now demand a combination of technical proficiency—particularly in digital and AI tools—with soft skills such as communication, empathy, and collaboration. For example, roles in project management and customer relations are now incorporating AI tools to enhance productivity while still relying heavily on human insight and emotional intelligence. As organizations look to maximize efficiency while providing personalized experiences to consumers, these hybrid roles present a promising frontier for job seekers, especially those entering the job market amidst the prevalent shift away from traditional entry-level positions.

Wrap Up

  • The contraction of entry-level hiring, alongside an increasing preference for experienced talent, signifies a pivotal transition within the global labor market as of July 2025. Employers are compelled to minimize hiring risks by seeking candidates who can deliver immediate value amid challenging economic conditions, thereby leaving recent graduates facing unprecedented hurdles. The ensuing landscape necessitates that young professionals proactively bolster their skill sets and differentiate themselves through the acquisition of human-centered soft skills and mastery in using AI-driven tools, establishing their competitiveness against seasoned professionals.

  • The responses from various regions highlight the urgent need for structured policies that bridge the skills gap and promote inclusive growth. Singapore’s economic initiatives, China’s innovative employment strategies, and the United States' focus on cultivating a Skilled Technical Workforce exemplify the collaborative opportunities available for aligning educational programs with industry needs. These integrated efforts will not only enhance graduate employability but also help create a more diverse and adaptable workforce moving forward.

  • Looking ahead, it is crucial for employers and policymakers to foster a balanced ecosystem that values both the fresh perspectives of emerging talent and the proven expertise of seasoned workers. Emphasis on continuous development and flexible training pathways will be fundamental to sustaining innovation and economic resilience. As the workforce evolves, the cultivation of hybrid roles that blend technical and human skills will present new opportunities for job seekers, signifying a future where adaptability and lifelong learning become central to career advancement. The road ahead demands resilience, collaboration, and a commitment to nurturing the workforce of tomorrow.

Glossary

  • Entry-level: Refers to positions designed for individuals who are just beginning their careers, usually requiring minimal professional experience. The current landscape as of July 2025 shows a drastic reduction in entry-level job openings, particularly influenced by advancements in automation and AI technologies.
  • Job Market: The marketplace for employment, characterized by the supply and demand for labor. As of July 12, 2025, the job market is experiencing significant turbulence, with a marked decline in available positions for entry-level candidates due to economic uncertainties and the rise of automation.
  • Experienced Hiring: The practice of prioritizing candidates with substantial work experience over those without. The shift towards experienced hiring has been driven by employers seeking reduced training time and immediate productivity, leading to a significant decline in opportunities for fresh graduates.
  • Automation: The use of technology to perform tasks with minimal human intervention. As of mid-2025, AI-driven automation is reshaping job roles and reducing the need for entry-level positions, particularly in sectors like customer service and finance.
  • Artificial Intelligence (AI): Technological systems designed to perform tasks typically requiring human intelligence, such as visual perception, speech recognition, decision-making, and language translation. As of July 2025, AI's expanding role in the workforce is significantly impacting job availability and requirements for new graduates.
  • Skills Gap: The discrepancy between the skills that employers require and those possessed by job seekers. The skills gap has been exacerbated by rapid technological changes, highlighting the need for targeted educational initiatives to prepare graduates for the evolving job market.
  • Upskilling: The process of learning new skills or enhancing existing ones to remain relevant in the workforce. As of July 2025, upskilling is essential for job seekers, especially as entry-level roles diminish and employers seek candidates with advanced abilities.
  • Economic Resilience Taskforce (SERT): A Singaporean initiative established in April 2025 to support the employment of fresh graduates in a challenging job market. As of July 2025, SERT is focused on enhancing employment rates through guidance and opportunities that link recent graduates with job openings.
  • ASEAN: The Association of Southeast Asian Nations, a regional intergovernmental organization comprising ten countries in Southeast Asia. As of mid-2025, ASEAN countries are collaboratively enhancing AI capabilities to address labor market demands, promoting skill development across various sectors.
  • Skilled Technical Workforce (STW): A classification of individuals in the U.S. workforce possessing specialized skill sets often without a four-year degree. Current U.S. policies aim to strengthen this workforce to address skill shortages in critical fields like manufacturing as of July 2025.
  • Human-centric Skills: Soft skills that emphasize emotional intelligence, creativity, and interpersonal abilities, which remain essential despite technological advancements in the workplace. As job markets evolve, these skills are increasingly valued among employers for their role in fostering collaboration and adaptability.

Source Documents