Covered Call Strategy ETFs vs Monthly Dividend ETFs: Comparing Income, Risk, and Investor Suitability

1. Summary

• As of April 23, 2025, a detailed examination of the investment strategies offered by covered call ETFs and monthly dividend ETFs reveals significant differences in income generation, risk profiles, and investor suitability. The mechanics of covered call ETFs like the JPMorgan Equity Premium Income ETF (JEPI) are rooted in an innovative approach that combines equity holdings with the sale of call options. This dual strategy allows JEPI to generate a reliable income stream from option premiums, even in flat or declining market scenarios. The ETF has been appealing to investors seeking a balance between income and capital preservation, particularly given its ability to cushion returns during market downturns, which contrasts starkly with conventional equity investments. On the other hand, monthly dividend ETFs and stocks, exemplified by the Harvest Diversified Monthly Income ETF (HDIF) and monthly payers like Manulife Financial, cater to those with a thirst for higher yields and straightforward cash flow management. HDIF provides an impressive annual distribution rate of around 10% and emphasizes predictable monthly payouts, making it an attractive vehicle for investors looking to cover regular expenses without the complications of fluctuating distributions.

• The yield comparison between JEPI and HDIF further illustrates the distinctions between these choices. JEPI’s yield, straddling 7.4% to 7.5%, stems principally from option premiums, offering security to those wary of market volatility. Conversely, HDIF's yields exceed 10%, leveraging a diverse portfolio to create robust cash flows, albeit with exposure to broader market fluctuations. Each investment type appeals to different risk tolerance levels—JEPI, with its cap on upside participation due to the nature of writing call options, versus HDIF, which affords complete exposure to positive market rallies. Thus, understanding how each vehicle reacts under different market conditions is crucial for investors aiming to select the right strategy based on their financial goals and risk appetite.

• In light of these comparisons, evaluating the risks associated with each approach highlights the advantages and disadvantages of using covered call strategies versus monthly dividend investing. While JEPI offers a downside cushion through income derived from options during downturns, it inherently restricts potential gains in bull markets due to its structure. Conversely, a focus on monthly dividends offers opportunities for both substantial yields and potential capital appreciation, but the absence of built-in downside protection can pose challenges during adverse market conditions. This analysis underscores the importance of aligning investment strategies with both personal financial objectives and market conditions.

2. Mechanics of Covered Call Strategy ETFs

• 2-1. How covered call ETFs generate income

• Covered call ETFs, such as the JPMorgan Equity Premium Income ETF (JEPI), generate income primarily through the sale of call options on the stocks they hold. This strategy involves two main components: investing in equities and writing call options against those equities. By selling these call options, the ETF collects premiums that serve as a source of income for investors. The fact that these options can be sold irrespective of stock price movements means the ETF can secure income even in flat or declining markets, which adds a layer of stability to income generation.

• 2-2. Structure of equity‑linked notes and option writing

• The structure utilized by covered call ETFs often includes equity-linked notes (ELNs), which facilitate the sale of options on a basket of stocks, typically indexes like the S&P 500. By engaging in options writing, the ETF can participate in returns associated with the underlying equities while limiting upside potential. This structure allows the ETF managers to dynamically adjust to market conditions by capturing premiums during periods of elevated volatility while maintaining their underlying asset growth strategy. However, if the market rallies significantly, the ETF holders might miss out on higher returns should the stock prices exceed the strike prices of the sold options.

• 2-3. JEPI’s strategy: asset allocation and option overlays

• JEPI employs a distinct strategy where it allocates up to 20% of its assets in equity-linked notes that sell call options, while the remaining portion is invested (up to 80%) in actively managed S&P 500 stocks. This dual approach allows JEPI to capture a majority of returns associated with its equity holdings while generating monthly income through the premiums earned from the options it writes. This blend of active stock selection and systematic option selling aims to stabilize returns and reduce volatility, making JEPI appealing to those seeking steady income and capital preservation in uncertain market environments.

• 2-4. Typical distribution frequency and consistency

• One of the defining features of covered call ETFs like JEPI is their distribution frequency. JEPI typically pays out dividends monthly, making it particularly attractive to income-focused investors. The consistency of these distributions is supported by the income generated from option premiums, which have shown to be reliable even in fluctuating market conditions. However, it is important for investors to be aware that while distributions occur regularly, the amounts can vary based on market dynamics and the performance of the underlying assets. For instance, JEPI's monthly payouts have ranged from $0.29 to $0.40 per share over the past year, highlighting the variability linked to its options income.

3. Overview of Monthly Dividend ETFs and Stocks

• 3-1. Features of monthly‑paying ETFs and equities

• Monthly-paying ETFs and stocks are popular among investors seeking consistent income streams, ideal for covering monthly expenses or supplementing income. These investment vehicles generally provide dividends on a monthly basis, which contrasts with the traditional quarterly distribution schedules seen with many dividend stocks. Specifically, these investments can mitigate the challenges posed by irregular income timing, offering investors greater financial predictability. ETFs like the Harvest Diversified Monthly Income ETF (HDIF) provide a diversified approach, pooling various income-generating assets to achieve robust yields. By incorporating a variety of securities, these funds can help to stabilize risk and ensure more consistent payout schedules, even in volatile market conditions.

• 3-2. Harvest Diversified Monthly Income ETF (HDIF) case study

• The Harvest Diversified Monthly Income ETF (HDIF), launched in 2023, serves as a significant example of a monthly-paying ETF. As of now, HDIF boasts an annual distribution rate of approximately 10%, providing unitholders with $0.071 per unit each month. The underlying structure involves a mixed portfolio of equities, bonds, and other income-generating assets, allowing HDIF to mitigate risk while maintaining high distribution levels. An important aspect of HDIF's strategy is its use of covered calls on a portion of its holdings, which not only enhances income through premiums but also serves as a buffer against declining market values. Nevertheless, investors should be aware that this strategy can limit upside potential in bullish markets.

• 3-3. Monthly dividend stocks (e.g., Manulife Financial, other TSX payers)

• Several individual stocks in the Toronto Stock Exchange (TSX), such as Manulife Financial (TSX:MFC), also offer monthly dividends. Manulife currently distributes $0.44 per share quarterly, translating to an annual yield of approximately 4.44%. For investors looking to generate substantial monthly income, this would necessitate a significant investment. Additionally, firms like SmartCentres REIT and Firm Capital Mortgage Investment Corporation provide reliable monthly payouts, with yields of about 7.4% and 8%, respectively. This diversified income approach highlights the attractiveness of selecting both ETFs and individual dividend stocks to enhance cash flow.

• 3-4. Pros and cons of monthly distributions

• Investing in monthly-paying vehicles offers various advantages and disadvantages. On the positive side, receiving monthly income can be beneficial for budgeting and cash flow management, allowing investors to meet their financial obligations more effortlessly. Furthermore, the frequent distribution of dividends fosters earlier reinvestment opportunities, potentially enhancing overall returns. However, the downside includes the potential for lower capital appreciation, as many high-yield monthly dividends are associated with mature companies that might not reinvest profits into growth initiatives. Additionally, investors must remain cognizant of the underlying risks, including market volatility and the impact of interest rate fluctuations on these investments.

4. Yield Comparison: Covered Call vs Monthly Dividend

• 4-1. JEPI’s 7.4–7.5% yield from option premiums

• The JPMorgan Equity Premium Income ETF (JEPI) currently offers a yield of approximately 7.4% to 7.5%, which is primarily derived from the premiums collected through its covered call options strategy. This strategy involves selling call options on a significant portion of its underlying equity holdings, generating income irrespective of market movements, although this approach also limits potential capital appreciation. In the current market environment, JEPI has been displayed as a reliable income-generating vehicle, appealing to income-focused investors seeking consistent cash flow without extreme exposure to market volatility. Furthermore, its low volatility has contributed positively to its appeal during uncertain economic conditions.

• 4-2. HDIF’s 10% distribution rate

• In contrast, the Harvest Diversified Monthly Income ETF (HDIF) provides a much higher yield of about 10%. This yield is achieved through a diversified portfolio that includes equities, bonds, and income-producing securities, strategically managed to provide reliable monthly distributions. The management of HDIF aims to deliver not only attractive yields but also stable income that can help to support an investor's cash flow needs more robustly than many traditional fixed-income products, especially in a low-interest-rate environment. The consistent payouts help to establish a predictable income stream for investors, making HDIF particularly attractive for those prioritizing higher yields in their portfolios.

• 4-3. Monthly payout consistency and variability

• Both JEPI and HDIF pay out distributions on a monthly basis, which is particularly appealing to income-oriented investors. However, the consistency of these payouts varies. JEPI’s distributions can fluctuate based on the performance of the underlying assets and market conditions affecting option premiums. The monthly payouts have been observed to range, but they are typically reliable, fostering a perception of stability among its investors. Conversely, HDIF’s distributions have shown a greater consistency and predictability based on its diversified investment strategy, thus injecting further attraction to those looking for stable cash inflow.

• 4-4. Income stability under market volatility

• During periods of heightened market volatility, JEPI tends to exhibit a more stable income due to its protective strategies against downturns, primarily through management's focus on lower beta stocks and its reliance on option premiums. Recent reports indicate that in turbulent markets, JEPI has consistently managed to cushion investor returns much more effectively than many other equity-based strategies, often registering smaller declines as evidenced in the stark comparison with broader market indices. On the other hand, HDIF also benefits from a diversified approach, which aims to mitigate losses during downturns, though it remains highly sensitive to the overall market performance of its holdings. While both ETFs can deliver monthly income, the manner in which they generate that income means their stability will differ under varying market conditions, making understanding these mechanics essential for investors.

5. Risk and Return Profiles of Each Strategy

• 5-1. Upside cap versus participation in market rallies

• The risk-return dynamics of investment strategies can often hinge upon the capability of a strategy to adapt to varying market conditions. Covered call strategy ETFs, such as JPMorgan's Equity Premium Income ETF (JEPI), impose an inherent cap on upside potential due to their strategy of writing call options against their equity holdings. This cap functions effectively in stabilizing returns during sideways or declining markets but restricts participation in significant market rallies. As evidenced, when the S&P 500 made gains, JEPI's performance was noticeably contained—limiting potential profits during bullish trends. Conversely, monthly dividend ETFs or stocks, like those discussed in the context of companies such as Manulife Financial and the Harvest Diversified Monthly Income ETF (HDIF), do not face the same limitation, allowing for complete exposure to market rallies. This aspect can be particularly attractive for growth-oriented investors aiming for maximum capital appreciation.

• 5-2. Downside cushion provided by option premiums

• A crucial feature of covered call ETFs is the downside protection they offer, which stems from the premiums received from sold call options. In recent market analyses, JEPI's strategy has shown effectiveness in providing a cushion during market downturns. In 2022, while the broader S&P 500 index experienced an 18.1% decline, JEPI managed to limit its losses to just 3.5%. This illustrates how the income generated from option premiums can mitigate the impacts of adverse market conditions, thus serving as a strategic buffer for conservative investors. On the other hand, traditional dividend-paying stocks or income-focused ETFs, while not bound by upside caps, do not inherently provide the same layer of downside protection. Their fortunes are closely tied to the underlying business performance and can face downturn influences more acutely.

• 5-3. Volatility management and drawdown mitigation

• Both covered call strategy ETFs and monthly dividend ETFs exhibit different profiles concerning volatility management. The embedded option-writing strategy in ETFs like JEPI helps circumscribe returns while offering a method to manage volatility. This method tends to lead to more stable income expressions amid fluctuating market conditions, as increased market volatility may translate to higher option premiums. In the current investment landscape, JEPI’s reliance on low-beta, value-leaning stocks is particularly notable, as this approach tends to shield it from excessive drawdowns that riskier investments might face. Conversely, monthly dividend strategies, such as those employed by HDIF or the discussed TSX stocks, are subject to higher volatility patterns, especially in fluctuating market environments. Thus, the choice between these strategies fundamentally aligns with the investors' objectives regarding capital preservation versus growth.

• 5-4. Expense ratios, tax implications, and fee structures

• Investors must also consider the cost structures associated with different investment vehicles when assessing risk and return profiles. JEPI, with a competitive expense ratio of 0.35% for an actively managed ETF, still poses overhead costs that can dampen returns, especially over the long term. Although this ratio is lower compared to many other funds, investors must remain vigilant, as higher periodic costs can erode the potential benefits of their investments, notably during flat markets. Conversely, many monthly dividend equities or funds may carry varying costs based on their operational structure, and tax implications differ dramatically between capital gains and dividend distributions. The latter is often subject to different taxation rates which may affect net returns. This detail underlines the essential nature of understanding not only the yield each investment offers, but also the net yield after accounting for fees and taxes on various income streams, ultimately guiding investors in the alignment of their choice with their investment profiles and tax considerations.

6. Investor Suitability: Aligning Strategy with Goals

• 6-1. Income‑focused versus growth‑oriented objectives

• When considering investment strategies, it is essential for investors to clearly define their financial objectives, as this will significantly influence their choice between a covered call strategy ETF like JEPI and a monthly dividend ETF like HDIF. Investors primarily seeking income will benefit from JEPI's strategy, which combines option premiums with a diversified portfolio of blue-chip stocks, offering a reliable monthly income through a 7.4–7.5% yield. Conversely, those oriented toward growth may lean towards monthly dividend ETFs that provide higher headline yields, such as HDIF, which recently reported a distribution rate of 10%. This distinction underscores the importance of aligning investment strategy with specific financial goals: while JEPI is best for those prioritizing steady income and lower volatility, HDIF could attract investors looking for substantial returns through dividends.

• 6-2. Time horizon and risk tolerance considerations

• An investor's time horizon and risk tolerance are critical factors that determine the suitability of covered call ETFs versus monthly dividend ETFs. For individuals with a longer investment horizon, the slightly higher volatility of monthly dividend stocks could be acceptable, as they may capitalize on capital appreciation opportunities during market upswings. On the other hand, JEPI's risk management approach—utilizing covered calls to generate income while limiting upside potential—makes it suitable for investors seeking to minimize risk in uncertain market environments. The choice between these strategies should thus reflect an investor’s personal comfort with market fluctuations and their anticipated duration of investment. As evidenced in recent market conditions, JEPI has maintained lower drawdowns, signifying its effectiveness in cushioning against market downturns.

• 6-3. Portfolio roles: core income, satellite income

• In constructing a well-diversified portfolio, investors must consider the roles of various investment vehicles. Covered call ETFs like JEPI often serve as a core income strategy, offering stability through consistent cash flow while cushioning capital preservation. This makes JEPI particularly attractive in volatile environments, as it provides a reliable income stream. Alternatively, monthly dividend ETFs such as HDIF may be viewed as a satellite income strategy, enhancing overall yields and potentially adding growth through capital appreciation. Thus, combining both strategies can offer a diversified income approach, balancing the stability of covered call ETFs with the higher yields of monthly dividend vehicles.

• 6-4. When to choose covered call ETFs over monthly dividend vehicles

• Investors should consider several factors when deciding between covered call ETFs and monthly dividend vehicles. Covered call ETFs, exemplified by JEPI, may be preferable during periods of elevated market uncertainty or volatility due to their lower risk profile and strategic use of options to generate income. For instance, in the recent turbulent market, JEPI's ability to limit declines highlighted its utility as a defensive investment tool. Contrarily, in bullish market conditions where growth potential is maximized—like the rally seen in 2024—investors may favor monthly dividend ETFs like HDIF that can capitalize on high-yield opportunities. Ultimately, the decision should be informed not only by current market conditions but also by an investor's long-term financial strategy, risk tolerance, and income requirements.

Conclusion

• In conclusion, the analysis of covered call strategy ETFs and monthly dividend vehicles unveils distinct avenues for generating passive income, tailored to diverse investor needs. As of April 23, 2025, strategies like those employed by JEPI showcase the benefits of stable income through option premiums while mitigating downside risks—a compelling choice for risk-averse investors looking for certainty amidst market volatility. Alternatively, vehicles such as HDIF stand out by offering attractive yields and regular distributions, appealing to those prioritizing significant cash flow in a predictable manner, albeit with the trade-off of greater exposure to market fluctuations.

• The ongoing examination of these strategies illuminates the necessity for portfolio architects to carefully evaluate their clients’ yield objectives, risk tolerance, and growth aspirations. The potential for a diversified income source arises from combining characteristics of both covered call ETFs and monthly dividend stocks, enabling investors to harness the strengths and mitigate weaknesses of each strategy. As market dynamics continue to evolve, it is essential for investors to regularly monitor their income-generating investments, considering factors like fees and taxation which can significantly influence net outcomes. Looking forward, strategic adaptions in investment approaches are likely to be critical, especially in light of broader economic shifts anticipated in the coming months and years.

• Ultimately, the choice between covered call ETFs and monthly dividend ETFs shapes not only the immediate income flow but also the long-term financial wellbeing of investors. Forward-thinking investors will need to remain vigilant, continually recalibrating their strategies as new market opportunities emerge, ensuring alignment with their financial goals in an ever-changing landscape.

Glossary

• Covered Call Strategy: A covered call strategy involves holding a long position in an asset while selling call options on that same asset. This strategy is typically employed to generate additional income through the premiums received from selling the options, while maintaining ownership of the underlying asset. It can provide downside protection but limits upside potential, especially during rising markets.

• Exchange-Traded Fund (ETF): An ETF is an investment fund that holds a collection of assets—such as stocks or bonds—and trades on stock exchanges similar to individual stocks. ETFs are popular for their flexibility, liquidity, and typically lower expense ratios compared to mutual funds, allowing investors to gain exposure to various market segments.

• Passive Income: Passive income refers to earnings generated from an investment that does not require active effort from the recipient. Common sources of passive income include dividends from stocks, interest from bonds, and rental income from real estate. Investors often seek passive income to supplement their regular income streams.

• Yield: Yield is a financial term that describes the income generated from an investment, typically expressed as a percentage of the investment's cost or current market value. In the context of ETFs, yield can include income from dividends or option premiums. A higher yield may indicate greater income potential, but it can also come with increased risk.

• Volatility: Volatility refers to the degree of variation in the price of a financial asset over time. It is often used as a measure of risk; higher volatility indicates greater price fluctuations, while lower volatility suggests more stable prices. Investors may prefer investments with lower volatility during uncertain market conditions to reduce risk.

• Risk Profile: A risk profile is a comprehensive assessment of an investor's willingness and ability to take risks when investing. It considers factors like investment goals, time horizon, financial situation, and risk tolerance. Understanding one’s risk profile aids in making informed investment decisions aligned with personal financial objectives.

• JPMorgan Equity Premium Income ETF (JEPI): JEPI is an ETF managed by JPMorgan that employs an options strategy, primarily selling call options on equities to generate income. As of April 23, 2025, JEPI delivers a yield of approximately 7.4%–7.5%, making it an attractive option for income-focused investors looking for stable returns during fluctuating market conditions.

• Harvest Diversified Monthly Income ETF (HDIF): HDIF is a monthly-paying ETF that provides investors with diversified income from a range of assets, such as equities and bonds. Launched in 2023, as of April 23, 2025, it boasts an impressive yield of around 10%, appealing to investors seeking robust monthly cash flow with potential capital appreciation.

• Monthly Dividend Stocks: Monthly dividend stocks are equities that distribute dividends to shareholders on a monthly basis, as opposed to the more common quarterly distribution schedule. These stocks are particularly appealing to investors who prefer regular income and cash flow for budgeting or covering expenses.

• Capital Appreciation: Capital appreciation refers to the increase in the value of an asset over time. This growth can result from changes in market demand, improvements in company performance, or broader economic conditions. Investors often seek capital appreciation as a key objective of their investment strategy, particularly in growth-oriented investing.

• Option Premium: An option premium is the price that an option buyer pays to the option seller (writer) for the rights granted by the option. This premium is a critical component of strategies like covered calls, where the income generated from selling these options can provide additional revenue for investors, regardless of the price movements of the underlying asset.

Source Documents

• A 10% Dividend Stock Paying Cash Every Month | The Motley Fool Canadahttps://www.fool.ca/2025/04/07/a-10-dividend-stock-paying-cash-every-month/
• JPMorgan's JEPI ETF gains investor interesthttps://www.selfemployed.com/news/jpmorgans-jepi-etf-gains-investor-interest/
• JEPI ETF Offers Profitable Safe Haven Amid Stock Market Bloodbath | Markets Insiderhttps://markets.businessinsider.com/news/stocks/jepi-etf-offers-profitable-safe-haven-amid-stock-market-bloodbath-1034537870
• Risks to watch for JEPI's 7.4% yieldhttps://www.selfemployed.com/news/risks-to-watch-for-jepis-7-4-yield/
• JEPI ETF Offers Profitable Safe Haven Amid Stock Market Bloodbath - TipRanks.comhttps://www.tipranks.com/news/jepi-etf-offers-profitable-safe-haven-amid-stock-market-bloodbath
• How to Get $500 in Monthly Dividends From Manulife Stock in a World of High Borrowing Costs | The Motley Fool Canadahttps://www.fool.ca/2025/04/21/how-to-get-500-in-monthly-dividends-from-manulife-stock-in-a-world-of-high-borrowing-costs/
• Cash Kings: 3 TSX Stocks That Pay Monthly | The Motley Fool Canadahttps://www.fool.ca/2025/04/22/cash-kings-3-tsx-stocks-that-pay-monthly-4/