Your browser does not support JavaScript!

Competitive Analysis of Intel Arc GPU vs AMD Radeon 780M

GOOVER DAILY REPORT July 26, 2024
goover

TABLE OF CONTENTS

  1. Summary
  2. Introduction to Intel Arc GPU
  3. Introduction to AMD Radeon 780M
  4. Performance Comparison
  5. Technological Advancements and Compatibility
  6. Market Position and Future Prospects
  7. Conclusion

1. Summary

  • The report titled 'Competitive Analysis of Intel Arc GPU vs AMD Radeon 780M' examines the performance and technological aspects of Intel's Arc GPU and AMD's Radeon 780M. It aims to provide a comprehensive comparison using benchmarks, driver updates, and user experiences. The report details the architectures, design, and performance specifications of both GPUs, noting Intel Arc's advancement in technologies such as DX12 Ultimate and AI frame generation (XeSS). AMD's Radeon 780M, however, demonstrates superior performance due to its RDNA3 architecture and higher clock speeds, making it the fastest integrated GPU in early 2023. Despite Intel's ongoing improvements, including significant driver updates, the AMD Radeon 780M still holds an edge in several gaming scenarios and benchmark performances.

2. Introduction to Intel Arc GPU

  • 2-1. Architecture and Design

  • The Intel Arc GPU utilizes an 8-core architecture running at up to 2.30 GHz. It offers a significant upgrade over the older Xe-series integrated GPUs, delivering performance almost as fast as the GTX 1650 (Laptop) and the RTX 2050 (Laptop). This positions it as a competitive alternative to the AMD Radeon 780M.

  • 2-2. Performance Specifications

  • Graphics performance of the Intel Arc GPU varies depending on factors such as CPU power limits, cooling efficiency, and memory speed. For optimal performance, Intel emphasizes the necessity of a multi-channel RAM configuration. The Arc GPU supports up to four SUHD 4320p monitors and offers both hardware encoding and decoding capabilities for key video codecs including AVC, HEVC, and AV1. These specifications place it solidly in competition with other high-performance graphics adapters.

  • 2-3. Technological Features (DX12 Ultimate, Ray Tracing, XeSS)

  • The Intel Arc GPU is a proper DirectX 12 Ultimate adapter, supporting advanced technologies such as ray tracing and AI frame generation (XeSS). These features enable the Arc to deliver cutting-edge graphical performance and efficiency. The GPU's capability to handle advanced rendering techniques makes it a viable option for gaming and other graphically intense applications.

3. Introduction to AMD Radeon 780M

  • 3-1. Architecture and Design

  • The AMD Radeon 780M is an integrated GPU in the Ryzen 7040 series for laptops, also known as 'Phoenix,' including examples such as the Ryzen 9 7940HS. This GPU is based on the RDNA3 architecture, which is the latest iteration from AMD. The Radeon 780M features 12 Compute Units (CUs), equivalent to 768 shaders, and has clock speeds of up to 3 GHz, depending on the CPU model it is paired with. Its design follows its predecessor, the Radeon 680M, and encompasses improvements in component integration aimed at enhancing performance and efficiency.

  • 3-2. Performance Specifications

  • With its new RDNA3 architecture and increased clock speeds, the Radeon 780M provides higher performance compared to its predecessor, the Radeon 680M. It is identified as the fastest integrated GPU (iGPU) available in early 2023. The higher clock speeds allow it to tackle more demanding games at minimum graphics settings, such as Cyberpunk 2077, and less demanding games like FIFA 23 at higher settings and resolutions (1080p). This performance leap is attributed to the increased number of shaders and the overall architectural enhancements.

  • 3-3. Technological Features (RDNA3, Ray Tracing)

  • The Radeon 780M supports a variety of modern graphical standards and technologies due to its RDNA3 architecture. This includes hardware ray tracing, although it should be noted that the performance for ray tracing may not be sufficient for current high-demand games. In addition to ray tracing, the GPU supports other advanced graphical features, making it applicable for contemporary gaming and multimedia applications. The RDNA3 architecture further ensures better overall efficiency and enhanced graphics output, maintaining AMD's competitive edge in the iGPU market.

4. Performance Comparison

  • 4-1. Benchmark Results

  • According to the data, AMD's Radeon 780M achieves an OpenCL score of 30,151 in Geekbench 6. This score reflects a significant performance improvement compared to older Radeon GPUs, such as the RX 480 with an OpenCL score of 42,732 and the GeForce GTX 1650 Ti with 44,561. On the other hand, Intel's 8-core Arc GPU, while competitive, does not specifically have these detailed results listed. However, the Arch GPU is noted to be almost as fast as the GTX 1650 (Laptop) and RTX 2050 (Laptop), indicating solid performance gains over Intel's older Xe-series GPUs.

  • 4-2. Gaming Performance

  • In terms of gaming, the AMD Radeon 780M, integrated into the Ryzen 7040 series, is reported to be capable of handling demanding games at minimum settings and less demanding games at higher settings and resolutions (1080p), thanks to its RDNA3 architecture and 12 CUs clocked up to 3 GHz. Meanwhile, Intel's Arc GPU, part of the Core Ultra 7 155H, supports modern graphics standards such as DX12 Ultimate and technologies like ray tracing and AI frame generation (XeSS). However, the actual gaming performance may vary depending on the CPU power limits, cooling solution, and RAM configuration of the system.

  • 4-3. Power Consumption

  • The referenced documents do not provide specific numerical values for the power consumption of either GPU. However, it is mentioned that the performance and power efficiency of Intel's Arc GPU can be significantly influenced by system variables like CPU power limits, cooling solutions, and RAM speed. On the other hand, AMD’s Radeon 780M's power consumption specifics are not directly addressed, though its performance capabilities suggest a design focused on balancing power usage and efficiency.

5. Technological Advancements and Compatibility

  • 5-1. Driver Updates and Impact

  • Many driver updates later, Intel Arc GPUs are finally able to run games at a decent frame rate. However, they still struggle with older DirectX 9 and 11 games, such as Grand Theft Auto V. An October 2023 update increased FPS by 149% in Starfield, but drops below 30 FPS can still occur in certain parts. Additionally, Intel Arc GPUs experience frequent crashes or serious FPS issues in specific games. Intel is actively working on fixing these problems, but high power consumption when idle, especially with multiple displays connected, remains a notable issue.

  • 5-2. Compatibility with Modern Software and Games

  • The 8-core Arc GPU running at up to 2.30 GHz is considered a proper alternative to the Radeon 780M. It performs competitively when stacked against GPUs like the GTX 1650 (Laptop) and RTX 2050 (Laptop). The Intel Arc is a proper DX12 Ultimate graphics adapter, and it supports ray tracing and AI frame generation technologies including XeSS. However, challenges remain regarding power consumption and the need for a robust cooling system to maintain peak performance.

  • 5-3. AI and Deep Learning Capabilities

  • Intel Arc GPUs support AI frame generation technologies such as XeSS, which enhance the graphical performance through artificial intelligence. These capabilities allow for smoother frame rates and more detailed graphics in modern games and applications. Despite some challenges in managing power consumption and ensuring stability across various games, Intel Arc's AI-based technologies represent significant advancements in GPU capabilities, potentially closing the performance gap with competitors like AMD's Radeon 780M.

6. Market Position and Future Prospects

  • 6-1. Current Market Position

  • The current market position of Intel's Arc GPU shows significant improvements over time, primarily due to numerous driver updates. Despite struggles with older DirectX 9 and 11 games, such as Grand Theft Auto V, Intel has made considerable progress. An October 2023 update, for instance, increased FPS by 149% in Starfield, although issues with FPS drops below 30 in parts of New Atlantis remain. Additionally, Intel's Arc GPUs face challenges related to high power consumption, particularly when idle with multiple displays connected.

  • 6-2. User Advocacy and Support

  • User support for Intel's Arc GPU is noteworthy. Enthusiasts, including popular channels like Linus Tech Tips, advocate for the purchase of Intel Arc GPUs to support a 'third' GPU manufacturer, thereby encouraging competition. This advocacy aims to prevent shortages during limited GPU supplies and to spur innovation in the market. The active user community on platforms like Reddit has even contributed to finding workarounds for issues such as high idle power consumption.

  • 6-3. Impact of Competition on Innovation

  • The presence of competition, particularly from AMD with its Radeon 780M, is a driving force for Intel's advancements. The AMD Radeon 780M, integrated into Ryzen 7040 series laptops, is based on the new RDNA3 architecture and boasts 12 CUs clocked at up to 3 GHz. This GPU supports hardware raytracing and performs well in demanding games at minimum graphics settings. The competitive landscape has the potential to push Intel to further innovate in GPU performance and efficiency, which benefits consumers through better performance and more favorable pricing.

7. Conclusion

  • The analysis reveals that although the Intel Arc GPU has shown commendable progress and competitive attributes, it still lags behind AMD's Radeon 780M in key areas such as gaming performance and power consumption efficiency. The continued updates and technological developments by Intel, including improvements in XeSS and ray tracing capabilities, illustrate a determined effort to narrow the performance gap. The limitations of the Intel Arc GPU, particularly in dealing with older games and controlling idle power consumption, need addressing. Future prospects for both GPUs indicate a competitive landscape driven by innovation, which promises enhanced performance and more competitive pricing. Consumers can expect these advancements to translate into better gaming experiences and more efficient hardware options in the coming years.

8. Glossary

  • 8-1. Intel Arc GPU [Technology]

  • Intel's Arc GPU features an 8-core architecture with capabilities comparable to the NVIDIA GTX 1650 and RTX 2050. It supports modern gaming technologies including DirectX 12 Ultimate, ray tracing, and AI frame generation with XeSS. Its performance is influenced by factors such as CPU power limits and multi-channel RAM setups. Despite initial driver issues, ongoing improvements are helping it compete in the GPU market.

  • 8-2. AMD Radeon 780M [Technology]

  • The AMD Radeon 780M, based on the RDNA3 architecture, is an integrated GPU within the Ryzen 7040 series. It boasts higher performance levels with 12 CUs clocked up to 3 GHz and supports hardware ray tracing. This GPU garners higher benchmark scores and demonstrates robust performance in gaming scenarios, positioning it strongly against Intel's Arc GPU.

9. Source Documents