Your browser does not support JavaScript!

Controversies Surrounding Lisa's 'ROCKSTAR' Music Video

GOOVER DAILY REPORT July 26, 2024
goover

TABLE OF CONTENTS

  1. Summary
  2. Plagiarism Allegations
  3. Criticism of Lyrics
  4. Controversial Use in Adult Entertainment Venue
  5. Public and Media Reactions
  6. Conclusion

1. Summary

  • The report titled 'Controversies Surrounding Lisa's 'ROCKSTAR' Music Video' addresses the multiple controversies that have surfaced since the release of Lisa’s solo music video 'ROCKSTAR.' The key issues discussed include allegations of plagiarism, criticisms of the lyrics, and the contentious use of the song in a promotional video by the adult entertainment venue Crazy Horse Paris. Gabriel Moses raised plagiarism claims, noting similarities between Lisa’s video and Travis Scott’s 'FE!N.' Social media reactions amplified the controversy, impacting Lisa’s reputation. Criticisms of the 'ROCKSTAR' lyrics, deemed superficial and lacking depth, were rife, with speculations of an internal diss towards BLACKPINK member Jennie. Finally, the use of 'ROCKSTAR' for promotional purposes by Crazy Horse Paris drew backlash due to the venue’s adult entertainment context, further complicating Lisa’s public image.

2. Plagiarism Allegations

  • 2-1. Gabriel Moses' Allegations

  • On July 6th, photographer and video director Gabriel Moses raised allegations of plagiarism against BLACKPINK Lisa’s "ROCKSTAR" music video. Moses specifically noted the similarities between Lisa’s video and Travis Scott’s "FE!N," particularly a scene featuring Lisa with 100 look-alike dancers dressed in white, which mirrors the aesthetics of Travis Scott’s video released on March 31, 2024.

  • 2-2. Social Media Reactions

  • Following the allegations raised by Gabriel Moses, social media reactions and public discussions intensified. Users on various platforms debated the similarities between Lisa’s "ROCKSTAR" and Travis Scott’s "FE!N," adding fuel to the controversy. The debate quickly spread across different social media networks, drawing significant attention to the accusations of plagiarism.

  • 2-3. Impact on Reputation

  • The plagiarism allegations have impacted the reputation of both Lisa and her team. As the controversy gathered momentum, it posed a challenge to Lisa’s image, especially as she ventured into the American market. The incident highlighted the complexities and scrutiny artists face in their creative expressions and collaborations, influencing public perception and media portrayal of Lisa.

3. Criticism of Lyrics

  • 3-1. Fans' and Critics' Mixed Reactions

  • Upon the release of Lisa's 'ROCKSTAR,' reactions to the song's lyrics were divided. According to NME, although the music itself was produced by renowned producer Ryan Tedder, the lyrical content was described as 'meaningless' or 'empty' by many listeners. Moreover, social media was flooded with comments suggesting that 'ROCKSTAR' did not live up to the expectations set by her previous hits like 'Money' and 'LALISA,' portraying it as a 'flawed' version of her past successes.

  • 3-2. Speculations of a Diss Towards Jennie

  • One major controversy surrounding 'ROCKSTAR' was the speculation that Lisa dissed her BLACKPINK member Jennie. This theory was supported by the perceptions of fans who analyzed Lisa's lyrics, which were penned entirely in English for the first time. Critics labeled the lyrics as superficial, stating they focus too much on self-promotion rather than deeper, more meaningful content. This led to further discussions on online forums and social media about the nature of Lisa's words and their potential hidden messages.

  • 3-3. Debates on Lack of Depth and Cultural References

  • Debates also emerged regarding the alleged lack of depth and cultural references within the lyrics of 'ROCKSTAR.' Despite the high production quality, many fans and critics noted that the song aimed for flashiness but ultimately lacked substance. The repetitive nature of Lisa's rap and the overall shallowness of the lyrical content were common points of criticism. Fans, however, have attempted to defend Lisa by suggesting that deeper meanings could be uncovered through further analysis of her words.

4. Controversial Use in Adult Entertainment Venue

  • 4-1. Crazy Horse Paris used Lisa’s 'ROCKSTAR' in a promotional video, sparking backlash

  • Crazy Horse Paris, a well-known upscale nightclub in France, used BLACKPINK Lisa’s latest single, 'ROCKSTAR,' in a recent promotional video. The video, which introduced the venue’s latest talents, sparked backlash from the public due to the association of Lisa's song with an adult entertainment venue. The nightclub posted the promotional video on its page on July 1, 2024, featuring performers in outfits inspired by marching band uniforms, with 'ROCKSTAR' as the background music. The public reaction was largely negative, with accusations that the nightclub exploited Lisa’s fame to gain attention for their sensual content.

  • 4-2. Public reaction to the use of her song by a venue known for adult entertainment

  • The online community reacted strongly against the decision to use Lisa’s 'ROCKSTAR' in Crazy Horse Paris's promotional video. Many individuals expressed their discontent and accused the nightclub of appropriating Lisa’s music for unsavory purposes. The controversy is particularly sharp because Crazy Horse is known for showcasing topless dancers in its performances. The utilization of 'ROCKSTAR' in this context has led to a significant wave of backlash from fans and the general public, who believe that this association is detrimental to Lisa's image and career.

  • 4-3. Previous controversies related to Lisa's association with Crazy Horse Paris

  • This is not the first time Lisa has faced controversy involving Crazy Horse Paris. Back in September 2023, Lisa performed at the venue, which led to intense scrutiny and criticism from various quarters. The recent use of her song 'ROCKSTAR' in the nightclub’s promotional video has reignited discussions and criticisms regarding her association with the venue. This recurring controversy underscores the challenges and public scrutiny that Lisa faces in her artistic endeavors and collaborations.

5. Public and Media Reactions

  • 5-1. NME's Review and Rating of 'ROCKSTAR'

  • The prominent UK music site NME published an objective review of Lisa's comeback single 'ROCKSTAR.' NME described the song as bombastic and grandiose, awarding it a rating of 3 out of 5 stars. While acknowledging Lisa's assertion of her 'Rockstar' status and her move in the right direction with this release, NME also noted that the single received mixed reactions. Some fans were disappointed with the content, finding it trendy yet meaningless or even empty, sparking considerable debate on social media.

  • 5-2. Online Forums and Social Media Discussions

  • The release of 'ROCKSTAR' by Lisa generated extensive discussions across online forums and social media platforms. The song's release quickly captivated the K-pop fan community, drawing both praise and criticism. Despite the impressive choreography showcased in her TikTok dance challenge video, which amassed nearly ten million views within just five hours, the music video was not without controversy. Allegations of plagiarism, cultural appropriation, and cliché lyrics were prominent themes in these discussions.

  • 5-3. Global Attention and Achievements

  • Despite the controversies surrounding 'ROCKSTAR,' the song undeniably showcased Lisa's global star power. Her dance challenge video on TikTok highlighted her exceptional choreography skills and received almost three million likes, emphasizing her broad international appeal. The song's reception demonstrated her influence on the global music stage, even amidst a backdrop of criticism and scrutiny.

6. Conclusion

  • The release of Lisa’s 'ROCKSTAR' has underscored the intricate dynamics of the global music industry, revealing the highs and lows of navigating public and media scrutiny. Despite the vigorous support from a global fanbase and significant attention to her TikTok dance challenge, the controversies encompassing allegations of plagiarism by Gabriel Moses, criticisms over superficial lyrics, and the controversial association with Crazy Horse Paris have presented substantial challenges. These events have highlighted the need for careful planning and authenticity in creative endeavors. While Lisa’s influence remains formidable, the report suggests that future projects might benefit from more depth and cultural sensitivity to avoid similar pitfalls. As the global music landscape evolves, it will be crucial for artists like Lisa to balance artistic expression with public expectations, potentially through more meaningful content and thoughtful collaborations. Future research could examine the long-term impact of these controversies on Lisa's career and brand image, offering a broader perspective on the sustainability of fame amid intense public scrutiny.

7. Glossary

  • 7-1. Lisa [Person]

  • Lisa is a member of the K-pop group BLACKPINK and has recently released a solo music video 'ROCKSTAR.' The report focuses on the controversies surrounding this release.

  • 7-2. Travis Scott [Person]

  • Travis Scott is an American rapper whose music video 'FE!N' was allegedly copied by Lisa in her 'ROCKSTAR' music video.

  • 7-3. Crazy Horse Paris [Venue]

  • An upscale adult entertainment nightclub in Paris that used Lisa's 'ROCKSTAR' for a promotional video, leading to significant controversy.

  • 7-4. Gabriel Moses [Person]

  • A photographer and video director who accused Lisa of plagiarizing Travis Scott’s 'FE!N' music video scenes.

  • 7-5. NME [Media Outlet]

  • A leading UK music site that published a mixed review of Lisa's 'ROCKSTAR,' highlighting its bombastic nature but acknowledging the criticism.

8. Source Documents